Lost: Via Domus
As The Series goes from strength to "eh?" to more strength, this game just looks more and more like a sharpened butt-plug viciously thrust up into the rectum of the unsuspecting consumer. In Lost: Via Domus' case, this gaming dildo is in the shape of a particularly rotten coconut. One that is multiplied throughout the game and just begs to be collected.
I'll admit that I've never actually watched the show, but I'm reliably informed that Via Domus' saving grace is its plot which is of interest to fans of the series. Sadly, this is turned on its head and driven face-first into the mat by woeful animation, hilariously bad puzzles, and a series of design mistakes that require you to die repeatedly.
This is one game you hope never escapes the island.